| Year | Games | One Game Playoffs | Semi-Final | Semi-Final | Spit Cup Finals |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1994 | 48 | Jamaica Pipe Dreams(Keith) defeat Rhinelander Blue Coats(Ken) | Hannibal Cannibals(Greg) defeat Jamaica Pipe Dreams 4-3 | ||
| 1995a | 80 | Pocatello Mello Yello(Greg) defeat Hairy Jesus Freaks(Keith) | Pocatello Mello Yello defeat Walla Walla(Ken) 4-2 | ||
| 1995b | 60 | Xanadu Honeydews(Keith) defeat Rocky Mountain Dews(Chris) | Xanadu Honeydews defeat The Armada(Greg) 4-2 | ||
| 1996 | 144 | 3 Evanston Vedders(Chris) defeat 1 Yuma Zima(Greg) 3-1 | 2 Oz O's(Keith) defeat 4 Cape Hatteras(Ken) 3-2 | 3 Evanston Vedders (Chris) defeats 2 Oz O's (Keith) 4-3 | |
| 1997 | 162 | Mystic Rhythm (Keith) defeat South Syrinx Friars (Ken) | 1 Mountain View Masters (Greg) defeat 4 St. Petersburg Apostles (Chris)4-1 | 3 South Syrinx Friars (Ken) defeat 2 Mystic Rhythm (Keith) 4-2 | 1 Mountain View Masters (Greg) defeats 3 South Syrinx Friars (Ken) 4-0 |
| 1998 | 162 | none | 4 Grand Junction Skillet (Greg) defeats 1 Harrison Cheeky Monkeys (Chris) 4-2 | 2 Manhattan Project (Keith) defeats 3 Pullman Porters (Steve) 4-3 | 4 Grand Junction Skillet (Greg) defeats 2 Manhattan Project (Keith) 4-2 |
| 1999 | 162 | none | 4 Andrews Red Rangers (Chris) defeats 1 Liverpool Longhorns (Keith) 4-3 | 2 Barstow (Greg) defeats 3 Hibbing Hurricanes (Joe) 4-2 | 4 Andrews Red Rangers (Chris) defeats 2 Barstow Dreamers (Greg) 4-0 |
| 2000 | 162 | none | 1 Austin T-Birds (Chris) defeats 4 Ypsilanti Yips (Steve) 4-2 | 2 Chilliwack Water (Greg) defeats 3 Corsica Red Devils(Keith) 4-3 | 2 Chilliwack Water (Greg) defeats 1 Austin T-Birds (Chris) 4-3 |
| 2001 | 162 | none | 1 Gilt Edge Splinters (Greg) defeats 4 Denali ASPs (Keith) 4-2 | 2 Black River Falls (Ken) defeats 3 Honolulu Hummers (Chris) 4-1 | 2 Black River Falls (Ken) defeats 1 Gilt Edge Splinters (Greg) 4-1 |
| 2002 | 162 | none | 4 Savoy Truffles (Chris) defeats 1 Gretna Rabid Dogs (Greg) 4-2 | 3 Zion Nuclear Gnatts (Ken) defeats 2 Soso Impersonation (Bob) 4-1 | 3 Zion Nuclear Gnatts (Ken) defeats 4 Savoy Truffles (Chris) 4-3 |
| 2003 | 162 | none | 1 Wilber Waiting (Steve) defeats 4 Shungnak Redemption (Dave) 4-3 | 2 Van Wyck Pirates (Chris) defeats 3 Oman Ice Man (Keith) 4-2 | 2 Van Wyck Pirates (Chris) defeats 1 Wilber Waiting (Steve) 4-2 |
| 2004 | 162 | none | 4 Panic Hiatus (Graham) defeats 1 Windsor Black Widows (Ken) 4-2 | 2 #(_^/>>> Whatever (Bob) defeats 3 Chautauqua Aquamen (Matt) 4-2 | 4 Panic Hiatus (Graham) defeats 2 #(^/>>> Whatever (Bob) 4-0 |
| 2005 | 162 | Farragut Shot Straight (Dave) defeats New England Sons of Sam Horn (Chris) 2-0 (Wild Card) Coulee Dam Whiners (Bob) defeats Albuquerque Quirky Albums (Matt) 5-4 (Division) |
1 Shady Dirt Roads (Graham) defeats 4 Farragut Shot Straight (Dave) 4-2 | 2 Kersey Bambinos (Ken) defeats 3 Coulee Dam Whiners (Bob) 4-2 | 1 Shady Dirt Roads (Graham) defeats 2 Kersey Bambinos (Ken) 4-2 |
| 2006 | 162 | none | 4 Festus Miracle (Dave) defeats 1 China Cat Sunflowers (Greg) 4-2 |
3 Kilamanjaro Thirty Helens (Keith) defeats 2 Mason Corner Avenging Angels (Ken) 4-1 |
4 Festus Miracle (Dave) defeats 3 Kilamanjaro Thirty Helens (Keith) 4-1 |
| 2007 | 162 | none | 1 Central Park Pepitones (Ken) defeats 4 Nice Guys (Steve) 4-2 | 2 Tin Pan Alley Gators (Matt) defeats 3 Cooperstown Santos Clause (Keith) 4-2 | 1 Central Park Pepitones (Ken) defeats 2 Tin Pan Alley Gators (Matt) 4-0 |
| 2008 | 162 | Santos Back to Back Jacks (Keith) defeats Avalon Abdicating Monks (Ken) | 4 Avalon Abdicating Monks (Ken) defeats 1 Escondido Stones (Chris) 4-1 | 3 West L.A. Fadeaway (Greg) defeats 2 Santos Back to Back Jacks (Keith) 4-1 | 4 Avalon Abdicating Monks (Ken) defeats 3 West L.A. Fadeaway (Greg) 4-0 |
| 2009 | 162 | - | 1 Burgundy Anchormen (Keith) defeats 4 Indianapolis One Game At A Timers (Steve) 4-2 | 3 Coconut Grove Jacks (Graham) defeats 2 Babylon Black Sedans (Ken) 4-1 | 3 Coconut Grove Jacks (Graham) defeats 1 Burgundy Anchormen (Keith) 4-3 |
| 2010 | 162 | - | 1 Grenada Survivormen (Ken) defeats 4 Cool Colorado Rain (Greg) 4-3 | 2 Porchtown Goodtimers (Graham) defeats 3 South Sandwich Islands Big Flies (Jim) 4-2 | 1 Grenada Survivormen (Ken) defeats 2 Porchtown Goodtimers (Graham) 4-1 |
| 2011 | 162 | - | 4 Aiken Forthecup (Chris) defeats 1 Verdana Salsa Verde (Ken) 4-3 | 3 Broadway Average Joe's (Keith) defeats 2 Wichita Jack Straw (Greg) 4-1 | 4 Aiken Forthecup (Chris) defeats 3 Broadway Average Joe's (Keith) 4-3 |
| 2012 | 162 | - | 4 Sic Semper Tyrannis (Ken) defeats 1 Loves Park Altogether Now 4-3 (Steve) | 2 Ding Dong Dingers (Jim) defeats 3 Rushville Surly Smoke (Matt) 4-2 | 4 Sic Semper Tyrannis (Ken) defeats 2 Ding Dong Dingers (Jim) 4-1 |
| 2013 | 162 | - | 4 Vader Taters (Jim) defeats 1 Greenville Four Wind 4-3 (Ken) | 3 Asbury Park Flying Fish (Chris) defeats 2 St. Louis Pilgrims (Greg) 4-3 | 3 Asbury Park Flying Fish (Chris) defeats 4 (Jim) 4-2 |
| 2014 | 162 | - | 1 Mountain Air (Greg) defeats 4 Leisure City 4 Baggers (Jim) 4-2 |
3 Boston Green Dragons (Gregg) defeats 2 Tishomingo Blues (Chris) 4-3 |
1 Mountain Air (Greg) defeats 3 Boston Green Dragons (Gregg) 4-1 |
| 2015 | 162 | - | 1 Flushing Bombs (Jim) defeats 4 Corcoran Cranberry Crackle (Ken) 4-2 |
2 Illinois Immortals (Chris) defeats 3 Lake Louise Mukluks (Keith) 4-1 |
2 Illinois Immortals (Chris) defeats 1 Flushing Bombs (Jim) 4-1 |
| 2016 | 162 | - | 1 Spase Wranglers (Greg) defeats 4 Mississippi Levee Breaks (Keith) 4-3 |
2 Winthrop Warriors (Chris) defeats 3 Uxbridge Purple Umbrellas (Ken) 4-1 |
2 Winthrop Warriors (Chris) defeats 1 Spase Wranglers (Greg) 4-2 |
| 2017 | 162 | - | 4 Atchinson Shake Rattle and Rollers (Steve) defeats 1 Trevelin Light (Greg) 4-2 |
3 Danville Yellow Bluebirds (Ken) defeats 2 Mango Mussolinis (Graham) 4-2 |
4 Atchinson Shake Rattle and Rollers (Steve) defeats 3 Danville Yellow Bluebirds (Ken) 4-2 |
| 2018 | 162 | - | 4 Gallion Discos (Greg) defeats 1 Hammond Hallelujah (Steve) 4-2 |
2 Ushuaia Southerners (Matt) defeats 3 Texas Hot Dogs (Ken) 4-0 | 4 Gallion Discos (Greg) defeats 2 Ushuaia Southerners (Matt) 4-0 |
| 2019 | 162 | - | 3 West Virginia Machine (Greg) defeats 2 Yelland Coal Miners (Ken) 4-2 |
1 Boulevard of Broken Dreams (Keith) defeats 3 West Virginia Machine (Greg) 4-1 |