| Player | Team | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Bonds | MVM | 60 |
| Sheffield | PETE | 52 |
| Belle | KHK | 51 |
| McGwire | JOE | 47 |
| Burks | JIM | 31 |
| Ramirez | KEN | 17 |
| E. Martinez | KEN | 16 |
| J. Gonzalez | PETE | 14 |
| M. Vaughn | JOHN | 14 |
| Griffey | JOE | 13 |
| Rodriguez, A | JOHN | 13 |
| Thomas | JIM | 13 |
| Lofton | JIM | 8 |
| Thome | KEN | 8 |
| Bagwell | PETE | 7 |
| Caminiti | SPS | 7 |
| Anderson, B | MVM | 5 |
| Henderson, R | MVM | 2 |
| Palmer | JOHN | 2 |
| Rodriguez, I | KHK | 2 |
| Knoblauch | PETE | 1 |
| Steinbach | JOE | 1 |
| Tettleton | JOHN | 1 |