| Season | Record | Ptg. | Etc. |
|---|
| 1998 | 5-13 | .277 | |
| 1999 | 10-8 | .556 |
Wild Card, Quarterfinals loser |
| 2000 | 13-5 | .722 | Division
Champ, AFA Runners-up |
| 2001 |
16-2 |
.889 |
Division Champ, Alternative Bowl IV Champs |
| 2002 |
11-7 |
.611 |
Wild Card, Alternative Bowl V Champs |
| 2003 |
10-8 |
.556 |
Wild Card, Quarterfinals losers |
| 2004 |
14-4 |
.778 |
Wild Card, Alternative Bowl VII Champs |
| 2005 |
15-3 |
.833 |
Wild Card, Quarterfinals losers |
| 2006 |
13-5 |
.722 |
Division Champ, Quarterfinals losers |
| 2007 |
16-2 |
.875 |
Division Champ, Alternative Bowl X Champs |
| 2008 |
14-4 |
.778 |
Division Champ, Semifinals losers |
| 2009 |
10-8 |
.556 |
Division Champ, Alternative Bowl XII Champs |
| Alltime | 147-69 | .681 | 18-6
playoff record, 5 League Championships |