| Season | Record | Ptg. | Etc. |
|---|
| 1998 | 13-5 | .722 | Division
Champ, Quarterfinals loser |
| 1999 | 13-5 | .722 | Division
Champ, Semifinals loser |
| 2000 |
15-3 |
.833 |
Division Champ, Quarterfinals loser |
| 2001 |
15-3 |
.833 |
Division Champ, Quarterfinals loser |
| 2002 |
12-5-1 |
.694 |
Division Champ, Quarterfinals loser |
| 2003 |
9-9 |
.500 |
Wild Card, Quarterfinals loser |
| 2004 |
6-12 |
.333 |
|
| 2005 |
7-11 |
.389 |
|
| 2006 |
14-4 |
.778 |
Division Champ, #1 Seed, Semifinals loser |
| 2007 |
14-4 |
.778 |
Division Champ, #2 Seed, AFA Bowl X loser |
| 2008 |
14-4 |
.778 |
Division Champ, #1 Seed, Semifinals loser |
| 2009 |
17-1 |
.944 |
Division Champ, #1 Seed, Quarterfinals loser |
| Alltime | 149-66-1 | .692 | 5-10
playoff record |