| round | Greg | Kap | Terry | Dave | Chris | Jim |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BJ^12 | Kan of Korn | Frazee Big Turkeez | Rockville O'Bombers | Qaud City Cyclops | Frenzied Fungi | |
| 1 | Pedroia 2b | Sizemore OF | Sabathia P | Cabrera 1B | Hamilton OF | Teixeira 1B |
| 2 | Markakis OF | Morneau 1B | Papelbon RP | Kinsler 2B | Holliday OF | Longoria 3B |
| 3 | Crawford OF | Quentin OF | Roberts 2B | Nathan RP | Upton CF | Granderson OF |
| 4 | Aroid 3b | Burnett SP | Halladay SP | Rivera RP | Ramirez 2B | Bay OF |
| 5 | Soria RP | Kazmir SP | Abreu OF | Ellsbury OF | Lester SP | Youk 1B |
| 6 | Vlad OF | Rios OF | Jones A OF | Ichiro OF | MartinezV C | Beckett Sp |
| 7 | Ortiz DH | Lackey sp | Shields J SP | Ryan RP | Fuentes RP | Andrus SS |
| 8 | Liriano SP | Wood K RP | Beltre 3B | Davis C 3B | Dice-K SP | Ziegler RP |
| 9 | Felix SP | Jenks RP | Percival RP | Joba P | Mauer C | Lee SP |
| 10 | Jeter SS | Morrow SP | Damon OF | Napoli C | Verlander SP | Wang SP |
| 11 | Francisco RP | Maggs OF | Toriii OF | Pena C 1b | Peralta SS | Wells V OF |
| 12 | Greinke SP | DeRosa 2b | Cruz N OF | Bedard SP | Gordon 3b | Choo OF |
| 13 | Huff 1b3b | Burrell OF | Lyon RP | Polanco 2b | Devine RP | Sherrill RP |
| 14 | Wieters C | Wood Br 3b | Young M SS | Slowey SP | Danks SP | Cano 2b |
| 15 | Baker SP | Dye OF | Shoppach C | Jacobs DH | Garza SP | Saunders SP |
| 16 | Konerko 1b | Weaver SP | Guillen C IF | Bartlett SS | Butler 1B | Litsch SP |
| 17 | Lopez J 2b | Aviles SS | Kendrick 2b | Sonnanstine P | Blalock 3b | Swisher of |
| 18 | Nady OF | Figgins 3b | Price SP | Santana E SP | Carmona SP | Lind OF |
| 19 | DeJesus OF | Pierzynski C | Thome DH | Murphy OF | Gomez C OF | Suzuki K C |
| 20 | Meche SP | Fields 3b | Floyd SP | Duchsherer SP | Hafner DH | Mathis C |
| 21 | Buerhle SP | Salty C | Inge C | Posada C | Guthrie SP | Downs RP |
| 22 | Ray C RP | Reyes P | Cordero C RP | Cust OF | Lowrie SS | Balfour RP |
| 23 | Teagarden C | Jackson E SP | Lowell 3B | Young Del OF | Snider OF | Shields S RP |
| FA | drop Balfour pickup Cabrera A IF |